Loaf Pan Conversion
The two common loaf pans differ more than they look…
The two common loaf pans differ more than they look: a 9 × 5 in pan holds about 8 cups, an 8½ × 4½ about 6. See how full the smaller one gets, and the scale for the recipe.
More optionsThe recipe’s pan filled ½ full
Wilton’s guide is ½ to ⅔ full for cake pans. Thin sheet cakes and bars sit lower.
ExampleScale the recipe
×0.85
An 8½ × 4½ in loaf has 15% less room than a 9 × 5 in loaf. Unchanged, it would be 71% full, past Wilton’s ⅔: scale by ×0.85 or keep some batter back.
Pick your two pans to see your answer.
9 × 5 in loaf8½ × 4½ in loafTop view, to scale
- Batter depth
- 1.5 in → 1.76 in
- Your pan fills
- 71%
- Baking time
- A little longer
The batter is deeper, so it needs longer: start checking at the recipe’s time and keep checking every few minutes.
How this works: 3 sources,
How this works
Method
A 9 × 5 in loaf pan and an 8½ × 4½ in one look alike on the shelf, but the bigger one has 45 square inches of top against 38¼, and is usually 3 inches deep against 2½. Cook’s Info measures them at 8 and 6 cups: the smaller pan holds three quarters as much. Full method
Sources
How it’s tested
2 worked examples for this page are checked by automated tests before every release: given the inputs, the tool must show the expected answer.
Privacy
On your device. Nothing you enter or open leaves this browser. About privacy labels
Changes
- First published: any two pans drawn to scale, with the recipe scale, batter depth, how full the new pans get and Bundt capacities.
Why loaf pans differ more than they look
A 9 × 5 in loaf pan and an 8½ × 4½ in one look alike on the shelf, but the bigger one has 45 square inches of top against 38¼, and is usually 3 inches deep against 2½. Cook’s Info measures them at 8 and 6 cups: the smaller pan holds three quarters as much.
So a 9 × 5 recipe in an 8½ × 4½ pan rides about 18% higher, and a quick bread such as banana bread can spill over. Either scale the recipe by about 0.85, or fill the pan no more than two thirds and bake the rest as muffins.
Going the other way, an 8½ × 4½ recipe in a 9 × 5 pan bakes a lower, wider loaf that is done sooner. Loaf pans taper towards the bottom, so the tool’s areas use the top size, as pans are labelled; both pans of a comparison are measured the same way.
scale = (8½ × 4½) ÷ (9 × 5) = 38.25 ÷ 45 = 0.85
- Cook’s Info measures a 9 × 5 × 3 in loaf pan at 8 cups and an 8½ × 4½ × 2½ in loaf pan at 6 cups, brim full. Source: Cook’s Info, “Baking Pans by Volume” (updated May 2022).
- Wilton’s guide is to fill cake pans half to two thirds full and to check for doneness at the shortest baking time given. Source: Wilton, “Ultimate Cake Serving Chart” (fill and baking guide).
A 9 × 5 loaf recipe in other pans
Scale that keeps the batter as deep, and how full each pan gets with the recipe unchanged (the 9 × 5 half full).
| New pan | Area (sq in) | Scale | Unchanged recipe fills |
|---|---|---|---|
| 8½ × 4½ in loaf | 38.3 | ×0.85 | 71% |
| 2 × 8½ × 4½ in loaf | 76.5 | ×1.7 | 35% |
| 8 × 8 in square | 64 | ×1.42 | 53% |
| 9-inch round | 63.6 | ×1.41 | 53% |
| 9 × 9 in square | 81 | ×1.8 | 42% |
| 9 × 13 in pan | 117 | ×2.6 | 29% |
| 6-cup Bundt | 6 cups | ×0.75 | 67% |
Common questions
Can I use an 8½ × 4½ pan for a 9 × 5 recipe?
With care. It holds about 6 cups against 8, so the same batter sits about 18% higher. Fill it no more than two thirds and bake the extra as muffins, or scale the recipe by 0.85.
Can I bake a 9 × 5 recipe as two small loaves?
Yes. Two 8½ × 4½ in pans have 76½ square inches between them against 45, so the batter is about 40% shallower in each and the loaves bake sooner. Check early; the tool shows how full each pan gets.
Will a loaf recipe fit an 8 × 8 pan?
Yes, with room: an 8 × 8 has 64 square inches against a 9 × 5’s 45, so the batter is about 30% shallower and bakes faster. Check early.